Zoom Calls Become Doom Calls Howey Test

Most people learn that they are selling Unregistered Securities first, and then they learn about the Howey Test… and then some go to jail.

Loading…
0:00 0:00

This is a clean, structured breakdown of the Howey Test questions and the possible charges that can arise when someone sells unregistered securities.

The Four Questions of the Howey Test

Courts and regulators use these four questions to determine whether something is an investment contract, which is a type of security under U.S. federal law. All four must be answered yes for the transaction to be considered a security.

  1. Was there an investment of money This includes cash or anything else of value.
  2. Was the investment in a common enterprise The investor’s financial outcome must be tied to the success of others or the overall venture.
  3. Was there a reasonable expectation of profits The investor expects to earn a return on the investment.
  4. Were those profits expected to come primarily from the efforts of others The investor relies on the promoter or a third party to generate the profit.

Possible Charges for Violating the Howey Test

If a transaction meets the Howey criteria but the promoter fails to comply with securities laws, the SEC or DOJ may pursue several types of violations. These can apply to individuals, companies, or both.

1. Sale of Unregistered Securities

  • Offering or selling securities without filing a registration statement or qualifying for an exemption.
  • Violates Section 5 of the Securities Act of 1933.

2. Securities Fraud

  • Making false statements, misleading investors, or omitting material facts.
  • Can involve violations of Section 17(a) of the Securities Act and Section 10(b) and Rule 10b‑5 of the Securities Exchange Act.

3. Unregistered Broker or Dealer Activity

  • Acting as a broker or dealer without proper SEC registration.

4. Failure to Provide Required Disclosures

  • Not giving investors the mandated information about risks, financials, or business operations.

5. Aiding and Abetting Liability

  • Individuals who help facilitate the illegal offering can be charged even if they did not directly sell the securities.

6. Criminal Charges (in severe cases)

  • Willful violations can lead to criminal prosecution by the Department of Justice.
  • Penalties can include fines and imprisonment.

7. Civil Penalties and Injunctions

  • The SEC may seek:
    • Disgorgement of profits
    • Prejudgment interest
    • Permanent or temporary injunctions
    • Officer and director bars
    • Industry bans